Apple Cider vs Other Dietary Vinegars

---

Vinegar has captured attention as a health remedy for thousands of years, from ancient civilizations to modern wellness enthusiasts. The Babylonians were using vinegar medicinally as early as 5,000 B.C., while Hippocrates famously prescribed vinegar-honey mixtures for treating wounds and respiratory problems. Even Roman soldiers carried "posca," a vinegar-water drink to stay well hydrated.

Today, apple cider vinegar (ACV) has become particularly popular, especially varieties containing "the mother" that cloudy, web-like substance you might notice floating in unfiltered bottles. This natural sediment consists of beneficial bacteria and yeast that form during fermentation, indicating the vinegar is raw and unprocessed.

Modern research has explored ACV's potential for blood sugar control and weight management, though results vary and some studies have faced scrutiny. A recent BMJ Group study on weight loss was actually retracted last month due to statistical errors. Despite centuries of use, it's crucial to approach vinegar's health claims with a balanced perspective. While this ancient remedy may offer some benefits, the science is still catching up to the folklore.

BMJ Group Retracts Previous ACV Study

In March 2024, a clinical trial published in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health made international headlines with bold claims about apple cider vinegar's weight loss benefits. The study suggested that drinking small amounts of ACV daily could help overweight and obese individuals shed pounds effectively. Within days, the research went viral across social media platforms, capturing global attention and sparking widespread excitement about this seemingly simple weight loss solution. However, the celebration was short-lived. Within months of publication, serious concerns began emerging about the study's methodology.

A study suggesting apple cider vinegar helps with weight loss has been retracted by BMJ Group, as of September 2025, after experts uncovered major flaws in its data and methodology. BMJ Group advises journalist and others to stop referencing a study that once suggested drinking small amounts of apple cider vinegar each day could support weight loss in people who are overweight or obese.

Dr. Helen Macdonald - Ethics & Content Editor at BMJ Group

By September 2025, the problems had become undeniable. The journal made the decision to officially retract the paper entirely due to the extensive collection of fundamental flaws. The study authors attributed the issues to "honest mistakes," but the damage to scientific credibility had already been done. Despite this flawed study's dramatic claims, apple cider vinegar does offer some legitimate health benefits, but they're much more modest than the viral headlines suggested. The truth about ACV lies somewhere between a miracle cure and a myth.

What the "mother" is and what it’s not...

The "mother" in unfiltered apple cider vinegar that is often marketed as having special properties is simply a natural byproduct of fermentation that may contain yeast and bacteria, as well as additional probiotics and enzymes. However, there's no concrete scientific evidence supporting claims that it provides unique health benefits beyond those of regular filtered apple cider vinegar. As nutrition experts have explained, dietary vinegar’s benefits come from its acetic acid content that is present in other types like red wine and balsamic vinegar.

While ACV isn't the magical weight loss solution that social media claimed, it's not snake oil either. Some studies suggest vinegar's antimicrobial properties can help eliminate certain harmful bacteria, and it may slow gastric emptying and reduce appetite, which could naturally reduce calorie intake. Remember to drink water afterward to protect your tooth enamel, and consider exploring other fruit-based vinegars along with red wine and balsamic varieties for both culinary and potential health benefits.

Health Benefits of Dietary Vinegar

For thousands of years, vinegar has been a staple in kitchens worldwide, valued not just as a flavorful condiment but also for its impressive health benefits. This fermented liquid is packed with essential nutrients and bioactive compounds that support overall health, from managing blood sugar to improving heart health. But, in recent years, modern science has attempted to validate some traditional uses of vinegar while debunking others. Moreover, when it comes to nutritional value, not all vinegars are created equal.

• Blood Sugar Control: Research suggests that dietary vinegar, particularly apple cider vinegar, may offer modest benefits for blood glucose management, but the key lies in acetic acid, which is vinegar's active ingredient for types, including ACV, balsamic, grain, and red wine.
• Weight Control: You might have seen wellness influencers online making social media posts promoting apple cider vinegar’s “the mother” as a weight-loss miracle. While it's been proven to not be a magical solution, there is enough science to back up some claims for weight control.
• Antioxidant Effects: Dietary vinegar offers impressive health benefits, primarily due to its rich antioxidant content. Vinegars like balsamic and red wine are particularly high in polyphenols, which are powerful plant compounds that protect your cells from damage caused by free radicals.
• Heart Health: Emerging research suggests that dietary vinegar, especially apple cider and balsamic varieties along with other antioxidants present in vinegar, may offer significant benefits for cardiovascular health. This is due to its influence on lipid metabolism, which inhibits cholesterol synthesis.
• Digestive Health: Acetic acid stimulates the production of gastric fluids, which helps your body break down food more effectively. This can reduce that uncomfortable bloated feeling after meals and improve the absorption of essential minerals like calcium and iron from foods consumed.

While apple cider vinegar isn't the cure-all that social media claims suggest, it does show promise as a health-supporting ingredient. Its acetic acid, B vitamins, and antioxidants can contribute to reducing inflammation and supporting overall well-being. When choosing a dietary vinegar, remember that darker varieties, like balsamic or red wine vinegar, are less refined and typically contain more antioxidants. Ultimately, dietary vinegar is best viewed as a supplement to a healthy diet and an active lifestyle, not a miracle cure for major health issues.

____________________

It's always important to have realistic expectations. Plus, if you decide to incorporate ACV into your diet, remember that its high acidity can pose risks. To protect your tooth enamel, it's a good idea to dilute ACV in water and rinse your mouth with plain water after consuming it. Metabolic Research Center has been helping people improve their metabolic health for decades. Take our 2-minute quiz to “Find Your Fit” and you’ll receive an instant download for our FREE Kickstart Guide that includes meal planning, recipes and much more.